| Chinese Sales | Reference Index | Home | Chinese Index |
MEDIEVAL CHINESE COINS
THE SUI, T'ANG AND POST TANG DYNASTIES
This is a reference guide to Chinese coins cast between AD 590 (beginning of the Sui Dynasty) to AD 960 (just before the Sung Dynasties). None of these coins are offered for sale, but a listing of examples we currently have available can be viewed on our : our vcoins store.
Images represent types, but bear no relationship to actual sizes.
SUI DYNASTY
AD 581 - 618
Many references list the first year of Sui as AD 589, but that is the date Sui unified China. Yang Chien, adopting the name Wen, established Sui in AD 581. As an official of Northern Zhou he had married the last emperor's daughter to become uncle to the heir, whom he forced to abdicate in his favor. In only nine years he expanded his territory until China was once again unified in AD 589.
EMPERORS OF SUI
| RULER | DATES |
| Wen Ti also known as Yang Chien | AD 581 - 605 |
| Yang Ti | AD 604 - 617 |
| Kong Ti You | AD 618 |
| Kong Ti T'ang | AD 618 |
Emperor Wen died in AD 604 with the traditional areas of China unified. His son, Yang Ti, continued the expansion with campaigns in both Vietnam and Korea but was killed in AD 617. The house of Chien had lost control of their empire, and a number of rebels vied for power, with Li Yuan and his son Li Shih-min (future Emperors of T'ang) gaining the upper hand.
Our list of Sui emperors is derived from Mitchiner (Oriental Coins and Their Values, Volume 1, page 699) but there is some confusion over the identity of Kong Ti You and Kong Ti T'ang. We assume these are Li Yuan and Li Shih-min, first emperors of T'ang, but are unclear as to why Mitchiner lists them as Emperors of Sui, as they appear to have established the T'ang Dynasty as soon as they were in control.
Emperor WEN
AD 581-604
At the establishment of Sui, the fiduciary coins of Northern Zhou and Ch'en were in use and the economy is recorded as having been in a poor state. Wen, showing an insight into basic economics, immediately re-introduced Wu shu on the traditional standard of 0.5 grams per shu but with a very identifiable straight-armed style on the character "WU", and unusual broad rims.
S-253, "WU SHU" with very straight arms on "WU" and wide well-finished rims. From 10 specimens we found an average weight of 2.63 grams and a size of 2.8 mm.
Today these coins are very common and must have been cast in immense numbers. While they are traditionally assigned only to Emperor Wen, we see no reason to believe the issue stopped at the time of his death. It is more likely they continued to be cast during the next thirteen years while Yang Ti ruled Sui.
The fabric is unlike any earlier coins but shared with the vast majority of later coins. The rims are broad and flat, while earlier coins usually have thin rounded rims. Even on high-grade specimens the characters are fast topped at exactly the same height as the rims, while earlier coins usually have thin round tops and can be any height relative to the rims (although usually lower).
The basic fabric of a coin is dictated by the minting techniques used to produce it. What we are seeing with this issue is an entirely new casting technology. For a basic discussion of this technique see our writeup under the Northern Sung Dynasty.
TANG DYNASTY
The death of Yang Ti of Sui resulted in a civil war from which Li Yuan (of Western Wei) and his son Li Shih-min arose victorious, establishing the T'ang dynasty and extending the unification of China for another 300 years. Li Yuan, adopting the title T'ang Kao Tsu, ruled from AD 618-626 then abdicated in favor of his son Li Shih-min who adopted the title T'ai Tsung and ruled from AD 627 to 649. Both were able rules under whom T'ang began its rise to greatness. The next 300 years was a time of relative calm, prosperity and enlightenment with the cultural arts dominating over the military arts.
EMPERORS OF T'ANG
| RULER | DATES |
| Kao Tsu also known as Li Yuan | AD 618 - 626 |
| T'ai Tsung also known as Li Shih-min | AD 627-649 |
| Kao Tsung | AD 649-683 |
| Chung Tsung | AD 684-690 |
| Wu Tsu-t'ien Empress | AD 690-705 |
| Chung Tsung 2nd reign | AD 705-710 |
| Juei Tsung | AD 710-712 |
| Li Lung-Chi also known as Hsuan Tsung (Ming Hsuan) | AD 712-756 |
| ????? son of Li Lung-chi | AD 756 |
| Su Tsung (full control) (nominal control) | AD 756-757 AD 758-761 |
| Shih Su-ming rebel | AD 757-761 |
| Tai Tsung | AD 762-779 |
| Te Tsung | AD 780-805 |
| Hien Tsung | AD 806-820 |
| Mu Tsung | AD 821-824 |
| ????? | AD 824-827 |
| Wen Tsung | AD 827-841 |
| Wu Tsung | AD 841-846 |
| Siuan Tsung | AD 847-855 |
| ????? | AD 856-859 |
| Yi Tsung | AD 860-873 |
| Hi Tsung | AD 874-888 |
| Chao Tsung | AD 889-904 |
| Chou We through puppet emperor Ngai Tsung | AD 905-907 |
Considering the almost 300 years and over 20 emperors of the T'ang Dynasty, the coinage is fairly conservative with only a few distinctive issues. For the most part, the standard K'ai-yuan type was all that circulated. For those emperors that issued coins, or emperors with important historical interest, a discussion follows.
Emperor LI YUAN
AD 618-626
Reign title: T'ang Kao Tsu, AD 618-626
The K'ai-yuan coinage, usually attributed to T'ANG KAO TSU, was cast almost continuously throughout the 300 years of T'ang rule, with the only major change the addition of mint marks in AD 841.
S-312+. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "K'AI-YUAN T'UNG-PAO" (Currency of the K'ai-yuan period). Reverse blank. There are three major variations of the character "Yuan". Average (17 specimens) 25 mm, 4.1 grams.
S-406. Iron 1 cash. Obverse: "K'AI-YUAN T'UNG-PAO" (Currency of the K'ai-yuan period). Reverse blank. Schjoth's sepecimen was 24 mm, 4.02 grams. Rare and of uncertain date. Value not established.
The general fabric and style of K'ai-yuan was the same as that introduced with the Wu shu of the Sui dynasty, but at an average of between 3.0 and 4.0 grams they are heavier. Wu (5) Shu was no longer expressed on the coins, but K'ai-yuans are Wu Shus by another name, cast to the official weight standard of 0.65 grams per shu rather than the coinage standard of 0.50 grams, an experiment seen earlier on the Ssu-shu issue of Emperor Wen, introduced in AD 430, as well as several other issues of that period. This was an enlightened move as, with no profit in casting full weight coins, counterfeiting was only profitable when light-weight coins were cast, which are more difficult to pass. The experiment must have worked as light-weight examples are seldom encountered. The economic stability thus created probably contributed greatly to the success of the T'ang Dynasty.
We do not actually know what the new denomination was called when first introduced, but it may have simply been known as a "K'ai-yuan". We know that some future dynasties called it that and even issued larger coins with the denomination designated in multiple "K'ai-yuan", but today this is the denomination we call the "Cash", which remained the basic denomination of China until the late 19th century.
There are hundreds of minor varieties, from subtle differences in calligraphy to various small crescents, lines and dots on the reverses. These differences probably identified specific issues, but the meanings of these codes have probably been lost forever. We are compiling a list of the major varieties in the hope that some pattern will emerge, but there is no guarantee of success.
S-312 variety with a star-shaped hole. "K'AI-YUAN T'UNG-PAO". Reverse: blank. The star-shaped hole is created by turning the center hole 45 degrees with respect to the inner rim. This occurs on so many different issues that it must be intentional, but the meaning is uncertain. Sometimes the star hole is combined with reverse symbols, in which case the example is worth a small premium.
SINGLE REVERSE CHARACTER
S-315+. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "K'AI-YUAN T'UNG-PAO". Reverse: single crescent, line or dots in any of various positions. We have no records of relative rarity for the varieties, so at the this time cannot assign any differences in value.
The exact position of these marks can vary from coin to coin, and we cannot be certain a crescent tilting slightly left or right is intentional or simply a minor shift in position. It is likely many types exist for each of the major calligraphy variations of "YUAN", which is certainly of significance. Our research in this area is just beginning and it is far too early to draw any conclusions as to the meanings.
| TOP | crescent out | crescent in | crescent out sl left |
crescent out sl right |
crescent in sl right |
dot |
| TOP RIGHT | crescent out | |||||
| RIGHT | crescent out | crescent in sl down |
vertical bar | |||
| BOTTOM RIGHT | crescent out | crescent left | ||||
| BOTTOM | crescent out | crescent out sl left |
crescent out sl right |
crescent left | ||
| BOTTOM LEFT | crescent out | crescent in | ||||
| LEFT | crescent out | crescent in | vertical bar | |||
| TOP LEFT | NONE NOTED |
* out - faces outer rim. * in - faces inner rim * sl left or right - tilts in that direction.
* the vertical bar may actually be a crescent with a very shallow curve.
We have not yet recorded an example with a single symbol in the top left corner, but all other positions exist with at least an outward facing crescent. One may turn up, but if not, this must have some significance.
TWO REVERSE CHARACTERS
S-335+. Bronze 1 cash. "K'AI-YUAN T'UNG-PAO". Reverse: two symbols (crescents, dots or lines) in various positions (less common than single-symbol types). We have handled one variety with crescents at top and bottom. The listed values are for that type. Some of the other types are scarcer.
| TOP & BOTTOM | thin crescents out | thick crescent out |
| LEFT & RIGHT | thin crescents out | crescents out left, dot right |
| TWO AT TOP | dot inside crescent out | |
| TOP & RIGHT | crescents out | |
| TOP LEFT & RIGHT CORNERS | crescent out in each corner |
* out - faces outer rim. in - faces inner rim
Schjoth lists a few examples with small dots in various positions on the obverse. We assume these to be casting defects of little significance and will include them only if we find out otherwise.
Emperor KAO TSUNG
AD 649-683
Kao Tsung, son of T'ai Tsung, extended Chinese control over much of Korea and part of Manchuria. He defeated the Japanese fleet, ending Japanese influence on the mainland for many years. The later years of his reign saw his father's concubine, Wu Tsu-t'ien, asserting power, probably ruling from behind the scenes. She proved ruthless, eventually seizing power in her own name (AD 705-710).
Title: Ch'ien-feng, AD 666-??
K'ai-yuan was probably the basic coinage of this period, but another issue was cast.
 |
S-350-351. Bronze 10 cash. Obverse: "CH'IEN-FENG CH'UAN-PAO" (Currency of the Ch'ien-feng period). Reverse: blank. At about 25 mm. Average (2 specimens) 5.0 grams. These are slightly larger and heavier than the normal K'ai-yuans. VF $135.00 |
We have not found out why this fiduciary 10 cash was cast, but the experiment failed with these coins being cast only briefly in AD 666.
Rebel Emperor SHIH SU-MING
AD 757-761
The rebel Shih Su-ming declared himself Emperor in AD 757 after killing Li Lung-chi's son. He controlled a large area, including the T'ang capital at Lo-yang and may have been more powerful than the official T'ang Emperor. As such, he was in effect the real ruler of T'ang during this period, issuing some interesting coins.
S-407. Bronze value 100 cash. Obverse: "TE-YI YUAN-PAO" (the currency of unity). Reverse: crescent opening upwards at the top. 35.5 mm. Schjoth's specimen weighed 17.45 grams.
FD-747, as S-407 but reverse blank. Bronze value 100 cash. Obverse: "TE-YI YUAN-PAO" (the currency of unity). Reverse: Blank. 35.5 mm. The one specimen we have handled of this type weighed 11.9 grams.
S-409, Bronze value 100 cash. Obverse: "SHUN-T'IEN YUAN PAO" (a currency agreeable to heaven). Reverse: crescent opening upwards at the top. Average (3 specimens) 36-37 mm, 20.5 grams.
At 36-37 mm and about 20 grams these are both fiduciary issues, circulating at 20 timesthe value in their copper content.
Schjoth reports an example of this type (S-410) with an incuse "WANG" on the reverse. We have never seen one, but consider the use of an incuse character to be suspect.
Emperor SU TSUNG
AD 756-762
While Shih Su-ming ruled much of China, Su Tsung (the legitimate Emperor) was working to restore order but did not retake the capital of Lo-yang until AD 762. In AD 758, probably to finance the war with Shih Su-ming, fiduciary coins were cast.
 |
S-355. Bronze 50 cash (?). Obverse: "CH'IEN-YUAN CHUNG-PAO" (Heavy currency of Ch'ien-yuan). Reverse: blank except for double rims. Average (6 specimens) 35 mm, 14.6 grams. F $25.00 VF $35.00 XF $48.00 |
At 35 mm and averaging around 14.6 grams, these contain 4 cash worth of metal but were first issued at a denomination of 50 cash. The resulting inflation and counterfeiting caused a major hardship to the people and they were quickly devalued to 30 cash, which failed to solve the problem and must have been a nightmare for anyone in possession of them. Over the following year smaller versions were cast, probably at five cash (30 mm, 7.5 grams) later devalued to two cash, and finally at one cash (24 mm, 3 grams), at which point the experiment ended and the regular K'ai-yuan coinage was resumed.
S-356-7. Bronze 50 cash ?. Obverse: "CH'IEN-YUAN CHUNG-PAO" (Heavy currency of Ch'ien-yuan). Reverse: crescent and double rims. 33 mm. Schjoth's two specimens weighed 10.73 and 12.92 grams. We have not yet established a value for this type.
S-358. Bronze 50 cash ?. Obverse: "CH'IEN-YUAN CHUNG-PAO" (Heavy currency of Ch'ien-yuan). Reverse: "CHI" (?) and double rims. 33 mm. Schjoth's specimen weighted only 7.92 grams while Mitchiner's (#3398) was 13.5 grams. There is some question if the character on the back is really "CHI", as on some specimens it is not solid and sometimes described as a cloud or even a bird. We have not yet established a value for this type, but it is scarce.
The effects of coinage debasement can be seen throughout history. One need only look around today's world to see how leaving the gold standard (effectively token coinage replacing silver and gold) has resulted in inflation everywhere, and economic devastation in many countries. The saying "history repeats itself" certainly applies here. Will we never learn?
 | S-352. Bronze 5 or 2 cash. Obverse: "CH'IEN-YUAN CHUNG-PAO". Reverse: blank. Average (4 specimens) 30 mm, 7.92 grams. F $12.00 VF $17.00 XF $27.00 |
There is also a rare series within this issue with what is sometimes referred to as an Auspicious Cloud on the reverse. At this point, we have not been able to determine the true reason or meaning behind these rare coins.
Shangi Encyclopedia #684. Bronze 5 or 2 cas. Obverse: "CH'IEN-YUAN CHUNG-PAO" (Heavy currency of Ch'ien-yuan). Reverse: Auspicious Cloud at the bottom, double rims. The only specimen we have handled of this type was 31 mm, 7.1 grams.
S-353. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "CH'IEN-YUAN CHUNG-PAO". Reverse: blank with single rim. 24 mm, 3 grams.
S-361-3. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "CH'IEN-YUAN CHUNG-PAO". Reverse: single rim and crescent (several varieties are known with the crescents in various positions. 24-25 mm, 3 to 3.5 grams). We have not yet established a value for this type.
S-364. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "CH'IEN-YUAN CHUNG-PAO". Reverse: a character possibly reading "YEN" and a single rim. Schjoth speculates this type was cast at Yen-chou-fu in Shantung. We have not yet established a value for this type.
Following the reign of Su Tsung the T'ang began a period of decline with real power shifting to the eunuchs at Court.
Emperor TE TSUNG
AD 780-805
S-365. White brass 10 cash. Obverse: "K'AI-YUAN T'UNG PAO". Reverse: blank. Schjoth (page 23) reports that in the 1st year of Chien-Chung, at Kuangtung mint, large K'ai-yuan coins were cast of white brass. We have never seen one of these, but he lists a specimen of 41 mm weighing 24.65 grams. This is at the lowest acceptable weight for a 10 cash, indicating this was not a fiduciary coinage. We cannot suggest a value for such a coin at this time.
Emperor WU TSUNG
AD 841-846
Reign title: HUI-CH'ANG, AD 841 - ?
Schjoth notes (page 23) in the first year of Hui-ch'ang (AD 841) many Buddhist monasteries were destroyed. The copper bells and images were melted and cast into coins. Li Shen, revenue commissioner of Yang-chou, received permission to place the character "ch'ang", short for Hui-ch'ang, on the reverse. It is likely this was done at other mints as well.
S-366. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "K'AI-YUAN T'UNG-PAO". Reverse: "Ch'ang" (indicating a coin struck in the year "Hui-ch'ang" (AD 841). This seems to be the only dated coin of the T'ang dynasty.
As with almost all K'ai Yuan coins with reverse characters, the reverse character will be somewhat weaker than the rest of the coin on this type (as explained below). We hope to replace this illustration with a better one when an example comes available.
K'AI-YUANS WITH MINT MARKS
Late in AD 841 it was decided to replace "Ch'ang" marks indicating the mint of issue. These mint marks were hand stamped into each mould, after impressing the main coin, with the result that they are often stamped deeper into the mould than the balance of the coin, becoming the high point on the coin and subject to the most wear. Others were poorly impressed and difficult to read on even the highest grade specimens. Only occasionally is one encountered with the mint mark as clear as the obverse, so our valuations assume the mint mark to be one grade lower than that of the obverse. Especially weak or strong mint marks affect the values accordingly.
| REF. | MARK | MINT | VALUATION |
| S-367 | Ching (at top) | Ching-chao in Lo-yang | not yet determined |
| S-368 | Ching (at top) (star hole) | Ching-chao in Lo-yang | F $14.00 VF $20.00 |
| S-369 | Ching (at top) (crescent below) | Ching-chao in Lo-yang | F $10.00 VF $16.00 |
 S-370-371 | Lo (at top) S-370 - round hole | Lo-yang in Honan | F $12.50 VF $17.50 |
| Lo (at top) S-371 -star hole | Lo-yang in Honan | F $14.00 VF $20.00 |
|
| S-372 | Yi (at top) | Hsi-ch'uan (Ch'eng-tu in Szechuan) | F $12.50 |
| S-373 | Lan (at right) | Lan-t'ien (Hsi-an-fu in Shansi) | F $12.50 VF $17.50 |
| S-377 | Lan (at left) (crescent at top) | Lan-t'ien (Hsi-an-fu in Shansi) | not yet determined |
| S-380 | Hsiang (at top) | Hsiang-chou in Chihli | F $12.50 VF $17.50 |
| S-381 | Hsiang (at right) | Hsiang-chou in Chihli | not yet determined |
| S-382 | Ching (at right) | Ching-chou in Hupei | not yet determined |
| S-383 | Yueh (at bottom) | Yueh-chou in Chekiang | VG $7.00 F $12.50 VF $17.50 |
| S-384 | Hsuan (at left) | Hsuan-chou in Anhui | F $15.00 VF $22.50 |
| S-385 | Hung - (at top) | Lin-chiang Fu in Kiangsi | F $12.50 |
| S-386 | Hung - (sideways at right) | Lin-chiang Fu in Kiangsi | not yet determined |
| S-387 | Hung - (sideways at right) (crescent at top) | Lin-chiang Fu in Kiangsi | not yet determined |
| S-388 | Hung - (sideways at left) (crescent at top) | Lin-chiang Fu in Kiangsi | not yet determined |
| S-389 | Hung - (upside down at bottom) | Lin-chiang Fu in Kiangsi | not yet determined |
| S-390 | T'an (at left) | Ch'ang-shu in Hunan | F $12.50 VF $17.50 |
| S-391 | Yen (at top) | Yen-chou Fu in Shantung | not yet determined |
 S-393-394 | Jun (at top) S-393 - round hole | Chinkiang in Kiangsu | VG $7.00 F $12.50 VF $17.50 |
| Jun (at top) S-394 - star hole | Chinkiang in Kiangsu | not yet determined | |
| S-395 | O-chou (at top) | Wu-ch'ang in Hupei | not yet determined |
| S-396 | P'ing (at top) | P'ing-chou (Yung-p'ing fu in Chihli) | VF $80.00 |
| S-397 | P'ing (at top) (crescent at bottom) | P'ing-chou (Yung-p'ing fu in Chihli) | not yet determined |
 S-398 | Hsing (at top) | Feng-hsiang Fu in Shansi | VG $7.00 F $12.50 VF $17.50 |
| S-399 | Liang (at bottom) | Liang-chou in North Hupei | not yet determined |
| S-400 | Kuang (at right) | Kuang-chou Fu in Kuangtung | not yet determined |
 S-402-3 |
Tzu (at top). There are a number of variations on this character. | Tung-ch'uan Fu in Szechuan | F $12.50 VF $17.50 |
| S-404 | Tan (at top) | Tan-chou in Shensi | F $99.50 |
| FD-734 | Gui (at top) | ??? | F $50.00 |
These coins are all bronze 1 cash with "K'AI-YUAN T'UNG-PAO" on the obverse
and are about 24 mm and between 3 and 4 grams.
We assume, but are not certain, that the K'ai-yuans with blank or symbol reverses were not cast once the mint mark came into use. The mint mark issues probably continued until the end of the T'ang Period.
Chao Tsung, the last real T'ang emperor, was assassinated by Chou Wen in AD 904. After placing Ngai Tsung on the throne as a puppet emperor, Chou Wen was in control but in AD 907 he deposed Ngai Tsung, establishing himself as Emperor of his new Posterior Liang Dynasty and bringing the period of T'ang to a close.
PERIOD OF THE FIVE DYNASTIES
AND TEN KINGDOMS
The fall of T'ang plunged China into turmoil, with power shifted through a series of dynasties, culminating in the establishment of the Northern Sung dynasty. Direct transfer of power from T'ang to Northern Sung involved five dynasties, but at least another 10 dynasties existed and influenced the history of this period.
Only some of the roughly fifteen dynasties are known to have issued coins, but the numismatic history of this period is rich and complex. There are many very rare issues that are not listed in the standard reference books, including some which have not yet been fully identified. We have started by listing only the more well-known issues, but when time permits we will be including more of the rare ones.
The following outline gives the sequence of events that led to the establishment of the Northern Sung Dynasty. It is beyond the scope of this site to include a detailed history.
| AD 907 | The last T'ang Emperor is killed, and Chu Wen establishes the Posterior Liang. Taking advantage of the resulting confusion, Li K'o Yang establishes the rival Posterior T'ang dynasty. Both dynasties are caught up in internal power struggles. Chun Wang becomes the second emperor when he assassinates his own father in AD 914. |
| AD 923 | The Posterior Liang Dynasty ends as Chun Wang is overthrown by Lo Tsun Hsu, son of the Posterior T'ang emperor Li K'o Yang. Lo Tsun Hsu becomes Emperor of Posterior T'ang in AD 927. |
| AD 936 | Posterior Chin begins when Shih ching T'ang, a Turkish general in the Posterior T'ang army, conducts a coup from within, with the help of the Khitan border tribe. |
| AD 947 | After eleven years of receiving annual tribute for their help in establishing the Posterior Chin dynasty, the Khitan disposed of Shih Chin T'ang, leaving the Posterior Chin throne vacant. Another Turkish general, Liu Chih Yuan, using the title Kao Tsu, established the Posterior Han. Fearing the Khitan, he immediately declared war and defeated them, but died the following year leaving his son on the throne (we have not found his name). |
| AD 950 | A coalition of generals killed Liu Chih Yuan's son, taking control of Posterior Han. |
| AD 951 | The leader of the coalition, Kou Wei, established the Posterior Zhou dynasty. Power transferred, in AD 954, to Kou Wei (his adopted son) who was in turn killed in AD 959, by his chief General Chao K'ung Yin. |
| AD 960 | Chao K'uang Yin took the reign title T'ai Tsu, as first Emperor of the Northern Sung Dynasty. |
Some of the additional dynasties that existed during this period were:
Liao (AD 907-1125)
Anterior Shu (AD 907-960/976)
Southern Han (AD 917-942)
Northern Han (AD 950-976/997)
Southern Tang (AD 907-978)
and Ch'u (AD 930-970's)
POSTERIOR HAN DYNASY
Emperor KAO TSU
AD 947-948
"Kao Tsu" was also the name adopted by the first T'ang Emperor. We have to assume this name was chosen to imply a connection to the family T'ang, thus establishing his right to rule. This name was also adopted by the first emperors of Anterior Shu, Posterior Liang and Posterior Chin, presumably for the same reason.
There is a record (Schjoth page 25) that in AD 947 mints were set up at the Posterior Han capital. In order to cast enough coins to pay the army, all copper was called in. This also had the result of suppressing counterfeiting by removing the raw materials from the hands of the counterfeiters.
S-411. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "HAN-YUAN T'UNG-PAO". Reverse: blank. 24 mm. 2.94 grams.
S-412-3. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "HAN-YUAN T'UNG-PAO". Reverse: crescent (two specimens, one at the top and one at the bottom. 24 mm. 3.75 grams. We have only had the blank reverse type and cannot provide a valuation for these at this time.
"Han-yuan" is a reference to the Han Dynasty, not a reign title. Issuing coins with this type of inscription is fairly common from about this time until the Northern Sung period. Schjoth had four specimens which averaged 3.48 grams, the same standard established during the T'ang Dynasty.
ANTERIOR SHU DYNASTY
Emperor KAO TSU
AD 907-918
"Kao Tsu" was also the name adopted by the first T'ang Emperor. We have to assume this name was chosen to imply a connection to the family T'ang, thus establishing his right to rule. This name was also adopted by the first emperors of Posterior Liang and Posterior Chin and Posterior Han, presumably for the same reason.
S-435. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "TA-SHU T'UNG-PAO". Reverse: blank. 24 mm. Schjoth's specimen weighed 3.15 grams. We have not handled one of these and cannot provide a value at this time.
"Ta-shu" is not a reign title, but rather a reference to the "Great Shu" Dynasty. For some reason Schjoth does not attribute this coin to any particular emperor, but there is a pattern all through this period where the first issue of each dynasty has a reference of this nature rather than a reign title. We can see no reason not to attribute this coin to the earliest issue of Kao Tsu, probably in AD 907.
Reign title: T'UNG-CHENG, AD 911-912
S-429. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "T'UNG-CHENG YUAN-PAO". Reverse: crescent at top, dot at bottom. Average (2 specimens) 3.18 grams, 22.8 mm. We have seen specimens both with and without the star hole in the center.
FD-771, as S-429 but reverse blank. Obverse: "T'UNG-CHENG YUAN-PAO". Reverse: blank. The specimen we recently handled was 23.5 mm, 2.65 grams and had very poorly developed reverse rims.
Reign title: T'IEN-HAN, AD 912-913
Kao Tsu adopted the reign title T'ien-han in AD 912 and at the same time temporarily changed the name of the Dynasty to Han. The name was changed back within a year.
S-430. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "T'IEN-HAN YUAN-PAO". Reverse: crescent at top. Average (4 specimens) 23 mm (range 22.5 to 24.0), 2.65 grams (range 2.0 to 3.1 grams). These tend to be somewhat crudely cast with a fairly broad range in size and weight.
Reign title: KUANG-T'IEN, AD 913-915
S-431-2. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "KUANG-T'IEN YUAN-PAO". Reverse: blank. 24 mm. Schjoth's specimen weighed 3.49 grams. From specimens of this type that we have recently handled, it appears that they type was fairly crudely and somewhat weakly cast.
Emperor WANG YEN
AD 918-925
Reign title: CH'IEN-TE, AD 918-924
S-433. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "CH'IEN-TE YUAN-PAO". Reverse: blank. 24 mm. Schjoth's specimen weighed 3.04 grams.
S-no listed. Iron 1 cash (?). Obverse: "CH'IEN-TE YUAN-PAO". Reverse: blank. 24 mm. No weight available at this time.
We had this iron specimen a few year ago and unfortunately did not record a weight at that time. The price listed is what we sold it for then, but we suspect it is probably worth somewhat more than that. There is a comment in Fisher's Ding (FD-775) indicating that Ding was aware of other iron examples.
Reign title: HSIEN-K'ANG, AD 924-925
S-434, Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "HSIEN-K'ANG YUAN-PAO". Reverse: blank. Average (3 specimens) 24 mm, 3.07 grams. Schjoth (page 26) reports that these tend to be very poorly cast and quite ugly coins. We have never seen a really nice one.
SOUTHERN HAN DYNASTY
Emperor: LIU YEN
AD 917-942
Reign title: CH'EIN-HENG, AD 917-942
Most coins of this reign title are of lead, with a fabric that suggests they are die struck, possibly with wooden dies, as they do not look at all like cast coins, with characters that are both very angular and shallow. There are two major variations on these coins that one occassionally see's :
| BLANK REVERSE | S-436 to 438, 1 cash made of Lead, "CH'IEN-HENG CHUNG-PAO", reverse: blank. The specimen illustrated is 26 mm, but Schjoth had three specimens ranging from 23 to 28 mm, averaging 3.7 grams. F $17.50 VF $29.50 XF $39.00 |
 | FD-828, Lead 1 cash. Obverse: "CH'IEN-HENG CHUNG-PAO". Reverse: "YONG" probably a mint mark. 25 mm, average (7 specimens) 4.2 grams. F $22.50 VF $29.50 |
Although we have never seen one, Fisher's Ding lists three examples of the "Ch'ien-heng" coins in bronze, as FD 829 to 831, where they are listed as being rare. The lead issues are normally seen grading VF or better, but are sometimes weakly cast (or struck). This suggests they saw little circulation, as any amount of circulation would quickly wear out a lead coin. It is doubtful people would have wanted to accept such an unusual issue that was obviously fiduciary.
SOUTHERN T'ANG DYNASTY
AD 907-978
The Southern T'ang Dynasty was one of the more powerful and stable of this period. One of several dynasties established at the fall of T'ang, it controlled large portions of China from its capital in Nanking. After 71 years and a succession of only four emperors, it was eventually overrun by T'ai Tsu of Northern Sung.
Emperor LI KUANG
AD 954-961
Reign title: Hsien-te, AD 955-?
S-439. Bronze 10 cash. Obverse: "YUNG-T'UNG CH'UAN-HUO". Reverse: blank. This is a large coin at 33 mm. Schjoth's specimen weighed 14.48 grams. This is a rare type. Having never seen one, we cannot currently provide a value.
Li Kuang was involved in wars of expansion in Southern China. These wars must have caused a strain on the treasury so, at the suggestion of minister Chung Mo, fiduciary 10 cash were cast at about 40% of the weight a 10 cash should have. Very few fiduciary coins had been issued in the previous 300 years and people were not used to them. This coin must have met with resistance and is recorded (Schjoth page 26) as having been quickly withdrawn. As the source of the suggestion to issue this coin, Chung Mo incurred the displeasure of the Emperor, which probably means he was executed.
S-440. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "TA-T'ANG T'UNG-PAO" in orthodox script. Reverse: blank. Schjoth's specimen weighed 2.16 grams and was about 21 mm, however a recent specimen we handled (illustrated above) was 4.45 grams and 23.7 mm. We are not yet sure if these are two different issues or (and more likely) Schjoth's specimen may have been an light weight ancient counterfeit.
This is a very unusual issue. During this period the "Ta-t'ang" inscription would normally have been used on the earliest issues of the Southern T'ang, normally the first or second year. All major references indicate these were issued about 53 years later in AD 960, the year the Northern Sung dynasty was established . Tthey may be a propaganda statement trying to announce the Southern T'ang was still strong.
S-441-442. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "T'ANG-KUO T'UNG-PAO" in seal script. Reverse: blank. Average 24-25 mm, average about 3.34 grams (based on 23 examples). This is a consistently well cast issue with clear characters.
S-445. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "T'ANG-KUO T'UNG-PAO" in orthodox script. Reverse: blank. 23-24 mm. Average (2 specimens) 3.77 grams, 25 mm. This type is normally fairly well cast.
Schjoth had two specimens, one of 2.2 grams and the other of 3.34 grams (our last specimens was 4.2 grams). It is highly likely the smaller specimen was a contemporary counterfeit and we have not included it in the average weight calculations.
FD-816, S-not listed. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "T'ANG-KUO T'UNG-PAO" in orthodox script. Reverse: large dot. The specimen we recently handled as 23 mm and 3.15 grams.
On page 26, Schjoth records that at the time of a money shortage these T'ang-kuo were valued at 1/2 Kai-yuan. This makes no sense at all. They are the same size and weight as a Kai-yuan, so at a time of shortage one might issue them at two Kai-yuan, but not 1/2 Kai-yuan. Schjoth had an example with "WU" on the reverse. If genuine (and that is not certain) it would suggest the intended denomination was 5 shu, which is the same as a Kai-yuan.
S-443. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "T'ANG-KUO T'UNG-PAO" in seal script. Reverse: "WU" (5). 24 mm. Schjoth's specimen weighed 3.76 grams. We have not had one of these, and cannot provide a value at this time.
Emperor LI YU
AD 961-978
S-446, "KAI-YUAN T'UNG-PAO" in seal script. This legend is not a reign title, but rather a reference to the Kai-Yuan coins of the T'ang Dynasty. Reverse: blank. 25 mm, average (17 examples) 3.3 grams
The old records indicate that 40% of Li's issues were of iron,
but these are seldom seen today.
POSTERIOR ZHOU DYNASTY
AD 951-960
Emperor SHIH TSUNG
AD 954-959
Because of a shortage of copper, in the second year of this reign (AD 955) Shih Tsung confiscated the bronze objects from 3360 monasteries, including all the images of Buddha, and cast them into coins. Many of these coins, being cast from melted-down images of Buddha and now are used as charms for midwives. The following year he ordered all publicly owned bronze to be turned in and forbade the casting of any bronze objects other than for official purposes, copying an order given in AD 947 by Emperor Kao Tsu of the Posterior Han Dynasty.
S-414, Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "ZHOU-YUAN T'UNG-PAO". Reverse: blank. We have seen examples with star holes. Average (5 specimens) 3.83 grams and 24.5 mm (we have seen a range from 23.5 to 25.2 mm).
Shih Tsung does not appear to have adopted a reign title. The "Zhou-yuan" inscription simply refers to the Zhou dynasty. This is a practice common to several dynasties in this era.
S-415-26. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "ZHOU-YUAN T'UNG-PAO". Reverse: crescent, bar or dot in any one of several positions. We have only seen a few of the types, but assume they are all of about the same value.
The following variations have been noted:
| POSITION | |||
| TOP | . | . | . |
| TOP RIGHT | crescent | . | . |
| RIGHT | crescent | bar | dot |
| BOTTOM RIGHT | crescent | . | |
| BOTTOM | crescent | bar | . |
| BOTTOM LEFT | crescent | . | . |
| LEFT | crescent | bar | dot |
| TOP LEFT | crescent | . | . |
S-427. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "ZHOU-YUAN T'UNG-PAO". Reverse: crescent at the top and a dot at the bottom. We cannot provide a value for this variety at this time.
S-428. Bronze 1 cash. Obverse: "ZHOU-YUAN T'UNG-PAO". Reverse: "MI" at the top. This is thought to be a mint mark for Mi-yuan at Shun-t'ien Fu in Chihli. We cannot provide a value for this variety at this time, but it should be worth more than the other types.
Schjoth had 15 examples from this series. The lightest one weighed 2.37 grams and the heaviest 4.61 grams, but the average was 3.28 grams.
CH'U DYNASTY
AD 930 TO ca AD 970
Ch'u was founded by Ma Yin, who was the governor of Hunan and part of Kuangsi during the late T'ang Dynasty and allied himself with Che Wen as the Posterior Liang Dynasty was established at the overthrow of T'ang. In AD 930 Ma Wen established the Ch'u Dynasty when he revolted against the Posterior Liang, but he died the same year. His Dynasty continued until absorbed by the Northern Sung in about AD 970, but we have found little further information about it.
S-447. Bronze 10 cash (?). Obverse: "T'IEN TS'E FU PAO". Reverse: "YIN" (probably a reference to Ma Yin). This is a large coin of 42 mm. Schjoth's example weighed 18.36 grams. Based on other coins from this era it is likely a fiduciary denomination of 10 cash was intended. We cannot provide a value for this type at this time.
FD-787. Iron 10 cash (?). Obverse: "T'IEN TS'E FU PAO". Reverse: blank. This is a large coin of 42 mm. Weight not available. The denomination of this coin is not certain, but it is likely a fiduciary 10 cash. We cannot provide a value for this type at this time, but it is very rare.
Ma Yin held the title of "the Chief Commander of T'ien Ts'e". The obverse legend of these coins, and the reverse of the following, refer to this.
S-448. Bronze 10 cash (?). Obverse: "CH'IEN-FENG CH'UAN-PAO". Reverse: "T'IEN". This is a large coin of 38 mm. Schjoth's example weighed 29.04 grams and is listed as bronze, but the size and weight suggest either iron, or an iron-bronze alloy is more likely. Iron was cheaper than bronze, an alloy of bronze and iron, at this weight, could have about the same metal value as S-447 above. We cannot provide a value, but this is a very rare type.
FD-791. Iron 10 cash (?). Obverse: "CH'IEN-FENG CH'UAN-PAO". Reverse: "T'IEN". This is a large coin of 38 mm. No weight is available at this time. We cannot provide a value, but this is a very rare type.
Ding Fubao lists a number of variations on the coinage of Ma Yin, most of them cast in Iron. The Ch'u dynasty was centered in Hunan, an area rich in iron, hence the large number of iron issues from this dynasty. Unfortunately this is a very rare series, seldom offered for sale.
UNCERTAIN DYNASTY
Recently a group of iron spade moneys, based on the bronze spades of the Hsin Dynasty of Wang Mang have come on the market. At this time we are not certain which dynasty is responsible for issuing these spades, but it is reasonably certain they date to the Five Dynasties period.
Unpublished (?). Iron, probably 100 cash (?). Obverse: "HUO PU". Reverse: blank. Based on the Huo-Pu spade of Wang Mang (S-148). Previously unpublished as far as we know.
 | FD-842, Iron 300 cash. Obverse: "HUO PU". Reverse: "SAN-PAI" (300). Based on the Huo-Pu spade of Wang Mang (S-148) Unknown to Schjoth, but Ding was aware of it in 1938. F $185.00 VF $275.00 |
Iron, 1000 cash. Obverse: "TA-PU HUANG-CH'IEN". Reverse: blank. Based on the value 1000 spade of Wang Mang (S-147). The reverse is blank. Ding and Schjoth were both unaware of this type, but it is catalogued in the Shanghai Encyclopedia.
The denominations of the 300 and 1000 cash are obvious, as it is stated on the coins. The 100 cash are not certain, but these appear to be part of a series for which 100, 300 and 1000 cash round coins were issued (reference FD-838-845), which we will list here later.
We recently had several of each of these spades which are reported to have all been found together. We purchased the higher-grade specimens from the hoard, but know there were a number of much lower grade and damaged examples. The values are what we recently sold them for. These are normally very rare and, now that this hoard has been sold out, it may be years before they are offered again.
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
Copyright © 1997 - 2001 R & T Enterprises Ltd.